Seafood restaurants

Fishin Fellas

4.7 123 reviews Closed 1337 Peach Orchard Rd, Sumter, SC 29154, United States

Discover this place

Welcome to Fishin Fellas, a hidden gem located at 1337 Peach Orchard Rd, Sumter, SC. This seafood restaurant has quickly garnered praise from patrons who rave about its vibrant atmosphere and delightful offerings. Customers appreciate the exceptional service that greets them upon arrival, setting a welcoming tone for their dining experience.

Renowned for its catfish and fried dishes, Fishin Fellas serves up culinary delights that keep diners coming back for more. Reviews highlight the fried bluegill served with hushpuppies and okra, which Brent Pokay proclaimed as items worth revisiting. Jack Laurent took a particular liking to the seafood taco, which he found oversized and satisfying, coupled with impeccable sides like crab fries that feature fresh crab atop crispy potatoes.

What sets Fishin Fellas apart is not just the food but the friendly and efficient service. Becca Johnson emphasized the rapidity of the service, even in a takeout-only setting, which does not compromise the taste or quality of the meals. With its diverse menu and focus on customer satisfaction, Fishin Fellas undoubtedly makes a strong case as a must-visit seafood spot in Sumter.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Takeout
Delivery

Popular for

Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Dining options

Lunch
Dinner
Table service

Atmosphere

Casual
Trendy

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Fishin Fellas before visiting.

Reviews for Fishin Fellas

4.7

123 reviews

100%

18%

Review highlights

Based on 123 reviews

Fishin Fellas is consistently praised for its high-quality seafood and welcoming atmosphere, making it a standout option in Sumter, SC. Reviewers frequently highlight the freshness and flavor of dishes such as catfish, shrimp baskets, fried bluegill, and unique offerings like crab fries. The restaurant’s casual, takeout-focused setup does not detract from the overall experience, as customers appreciate the fast and friendly service. Many note the enjoyable, relaxed vibe and the variety of Southern-style sides, including hush puppies and fried okra, which complement the main dishes well. These consistent themes of excellent food quality, attentive customer care, and a fun, approachable environment contribute to Fishin Fellas being seen as a reliable and inviting seafood destination.

renee Miller -Edwards

Jun 29, 2025

Great service, catfish was excellent! With hush puppies and fried okra to match. I will be returning for sure!

Meant 2 Be RVing

Jun 24, 2025

Just back in town and noticed the place, read the reviews and decided to give it a try. I had the shrimp basket and I must say it was perfect. The customer service was very pleasant from the moment we walked into the place. We will be back.

Brent Pokay

Jun 16, 2025

Just found my new favorite restaurant, such a fun atmosphere and great lady's, Had the fried bluegill hushpuppies and okra can't wait to try more things on their menu Tater

Jack Laurent

May 10, 2025

I ate here twice during a visit to Poinsett State Park. Fish tacos were huge, fries were perfectly crispy, and the slaw was simple but perfectly seasoned. And Crab fries! Fresh crab with a bit of sauce over crispy fries. Dang, those were unique and a meal by themselves. Bravo Fishin fellas!

Becca Johnson

May 09, 2025

Great service, very friendly, yummy food, and fast. Did not realize its take out. No dining room, but the quality of food made up for it!!

John Filler

May 03, 2025

The food was hot when we got it home! The flavors were off the hook! Flounder Tacos and shrimp tacos were seasoned perfectly and some of the best I have ever had! The hush puppies brought tears to my eyes with memories of time gone by! The service was very informative and professional! This is a must try for everyone in the area looking for good old fashioned southern cooking! Thank you it was amazing

Clifford Brooks

Apr 23, 2025

My mother loves the croaker meals from this establishment. The meals are never a disappointment. The turn around time is better than your average seafood restaurant who cooks a traditional fried fish meal with sides.

Andrew Barkley

Apr 10, 2025

We found ourselves craving some seafood, and decided to give Fishin Fellas a try! Very pleased we did! Food was delicious, great portions and came in quickly! Will be returning!